Article Reviews

Back to article

Congenital Bands: A Rare Cause Of Adult Intestinal Obstruction

Submited on: 24 Mar 2014 09:18:25 AM GMT
Published on: 17 Apr 2014 06:15:09 AM GMT

Please resubmit after checking for grammar and spelling.

 
Posted by Dr. Mark Mattar on 01 Oct 2013 07:34:59 PM GMT

The article presented does not contain sufficient scientific importance, there is insufficient scientific proof for the proposed diagnosis. The results are not appropriately interpreted and does not support the conclusions deduced. The manuscript is appropriately written and includes appropriate references but does not contribute to what is already known about this issue. The manuscript does not follow the appropriate guidelines for that type of study.

 
Posted by Anonymous reviewer on 01 Oct 2013 04:05:09 PM GMT

Based on the abstract a very interesting topic particularly if authors present a reliable way to distinguish congenital bands from postoperative adhesions.

 
Posted by Dr. Ziga Tretjak on 01 Oct 2013 02:20:48 PM GMT

  1. The manuscript should be cheked by an English native speaker.
  2. Please define abbreviations in the manuscript at their first occurrence.
  3. The following sentence should be clarified: ”Identification of such congenital bands in a previously operated patient for exploratory laparotomy is still rarer”.
  4. Please check for references format and annotations in the body text.

 
Posted by Anonymous reviewer on 25 Jul 2013 08:48:16 AM GMT